This blog is movie Review of movie 12th Fail, Directed by Vidhu Vinod Chopra. This blog is in response to the task given by Dilip Barad sir. In this blog I am going to write some Points which i have noticed during movie Screening of this movie.
12th Fail
Director: Vidhu Vinod Chopra
Cast: Vikrant Massey, Medha Shankar, Priyanshu Chatterjee, Harish Khanna, Sarita Joshi
Run-time: 147 minutes
Storyline: Manoj, a driven young boy from Chambal, overcomes societal hardships in his inspiring pursuit to join the Indian civil services
Jeero dass ko lakh banaye
Jeero se kya Darna bey
Jeero ke pahiye banake
Tu aage aage badhna bey
.jpeg)
Introduction
"लड़ाई के मैदान में आपका स्वागत है!
12th Fail is a movie based on the real-life experiences of Manoj Kumar Sharma, a police officer. Manoj, played by Vikrant Massey, comes from a poor family in Chambal. His father faces suspension for being honest at work. At school, the headmaster encourages students to cheat in exams. When DSP Dushyant, portrayed by Priyanshu Chatterjee, arrests the headmaster, he tells Manoj that honesty is crucial in life. Inspired by Dushyant’s words, Manoj believes that an honest officer can make a positive impact on society. The film explores Manoj’s journey to success and the challenges he faces.
Theoretical Framework:
In this starting frame we can find Establishing shot of Chambal, highlighting poverty and harsh realities. We can also find it is captured by a helicopter shot. This symbolic helicopter shot underscores the insignificance of cheating in Manoj's life. The film employs dim lighting, serene backgrounds, and gentle music to delicately portray characters' challenges and aspirations. Realistic sounds add authenticity, skillfully capturing Manoj Kumar Sharma's determined journey and conveying broader themes of resilience and education against social odds
Mirror view:
In this frame we can find while DSP Dushyant and Manoj talk with each other and camera focus on front mirror. We can take it as direct impact of someone.
.png)
In this scene, Gauri Bhaiya gracefully likens UPSC to a game of snakes and ladders. Manoj, navigating trust challenges, seeks the support of friends to restart in this intricate game. Gauri Bhaiya diplomatically describes UPSC as a journey where only a select few succeed, while others may need to restart or face setbacks.
Contextualization:
The film's portrayal of the fervent coaching culture surrounding the UPSC civil services exam taps into major discourses around India's education system and governance. It reflects intensifying pressures facing the country's educated youth population seeking white-collar jobs and upward mobility.
Manoj's family exemplifies the immense hopes parents invest in academic performances they see as make-or-break for their children's futures. His father risks his integrity over exam cheating, knowing clearing 12th standard can be life-changing. This mirrors middle class anxieties around exam results as society's sole meritocratic vehicle for progress.
Meanwhile Manoj's journey captures the jarring rural-urban transitions undertaken by many aspirants leaving villages for intense UPSC coaching hubs like Delhi's Mukherjee Nagar. The film examines estrangement and ethical compromises accompanying this geographic and psychological passage.
Broader questions about the role of UPSC exams in determining access to power also underlie public sentiment. Anti-elitist currents feed ideas that clearing an exam like this can empower ordinary citizens to shake entrenched bureaucratic cadres. Manoj's marginalized background elicits greater emotional investment in his underdog struggle.
So while one man's story, 12th Fail encapsulates numerous socio-cultural tensions - around exam pressures, resource divides, migrations for opportunity. It channels youth zeitgeist while interrogating systemic hurdles.
Thematic Study:
.jpeg)
In the movie "12 fail," the thematic exploration of the transformative power of education, corruption in the education system, the role of mentors, and the contrast between merit and privilege provides a nuanced societal commentary. The narrative underscores the significance of moral choices, hard work, and integrity in overcoming corrupt practices and social divisions. The relationship between Manoj and the reformed police officer exemplifies the triumph of idealism over cynicism.
In alignment with the themes depicted in the film, Barad's article, "The Changing Priorities of Education in India," resonates with concerns regarding the exclusive focus on government job exams. The film's emphasis on this pursuit is reflected in the negative consequences outlined by Barad, such as fostering a 'herd mentality,' sidelining diverse talents, neglecting genuine learning, and promoting an imbalanced focus on stereotypical 'safe options.' The prevalence of intense competition and the rise of coaching centers further highlight the need for educational reforms that prioritize diverse talents and intrinsic values over a narrow pursuit of government jobs.
Together, the film and the referenced article shed light on the societal implications of educational priorities, advocating for a more holistic and inclusive approach that values diverse talents and genuine learning.
Comparative Analysis:
.jpeg)
In comparing "12 Fail" with a Bollywood movie like "Super 30," both films address issues within the education system. "Super 30" is based on the life of mathematician Anand Kumar, who mentors economically disadvantaged students for the IIT entrance exam.
Similarities:
1. **Educational System Critique:** Both films critique the flaws in the education system, showcasing challenges and corruption.
2. **Social Commentary:** Both explore societal issues— "12 Fail" on corruption and social divisions, and "Super 30" on economic disparities and the pursuit of education as a means of empowerment.
Differences:
1. **Central Theme:** While "12 Fail" emphasizes the consequences of a singular focus on government job exams, "Super 30" focuses on overcoming economic barriers through education.
2. **Character Motivations:** The protagonists have different motivations—Manoj in "12 Fail" faces corruption and social issues, whereas Anand Kumar in "Super 30" is driven by a desire to uplift economically disadvantaged students.
Cultural Significance:
1. **Diversity of Issues:** Both films contribute to the rich tapestry of Bollywood by addressing diverse societal issues, reflecting the cultural and socio-economic landscape of India.
2. **Empowerment Narratives:** Both films embody narratives of empowerment through education, resonating with audiences and contributing to discussions on societal change.
While both films share a common focus on education and societal issues, their unique perspectives and character motivations contribute to the rich diversity within Bollywood cinema.
Conclusion
, "12 Fail Movie" appears to have faced significant challenges and shortcomings based on the review. The observations highlight issues such as poor plot development, unconvincing performances, and lackluster execution. The film seems to have failed to engage its audience and deliver a compelling cinematic experience.
The key insights suggest that fundamental aspects of storytelling, acting, and direction may have fallen short of expectations, contributing to a disappointing viewing experience. While specific details may vary, the overall sentiment conveyed in the review is one of disappointment and dissatisfaction with the film's quality.
Considering these observations, the film's impact and relevance are likely to be negative. A movie's success often hinges on its ability to captivate audiences, generate positive reviews, and leave a lasting impression. In this case, "12 Fail Movie" appears to have missed the mark, potentially leading to a limited impact and diminished relevance in the broader cinematic landscape. It serves as a reminder of the importance of strong storytelling, skilled performances, and effective filmmaking techniques in creating a memorable and impactful movie.
Refrence:
Chopra, Vidhu Vinod, director. 12th Fail. Vinod Chopra Films, 2023.
Kumar, Anuj. “'12th Fail' movie review: Vidhu Vinod Chopra delivers yet another hug of hope that is more earnest than magical.” The Hindu, 26 October 2023, https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/movies/12th-fail-movie-review-vidhu-vinod-chopra-delivers-yet-another-hug-of-hope-that-is-more-earnest-than-magical/article67460764.ece. Accessed 21 January 2024.
Mohan, Sajesh. “Review | Vidhu Vinod Chopra's '12th Fail' will inspire you to 'restart.'” Onmanorama, 28 October 2023, https://www.onmanorama.com/entertainment/movie-reviews/2023/10/28/vidhu-vinod-chopra-12th-fail-movie-review-vikrant-massey.html. Accessed 21 January 2024.
Satkar, Shubhangi. “12th fail Movie and Hidden Caste privilege: A Critical Analysis from Dalit Perspective.” दलित टाइम्स (दलित टाइम्स), 15 January 2024, https://dalittimes.in/twelfth-fail-movie-and-hidden-caste-privilege-a-critical-analysis-from-dalit-perspective/. Accessed 21 January 2024.
“12th Fail Movie Review: Vikrant Massey, Anant V Joshi-starrer is the India story!” Mid-day, 27 October 2023, https://www.mid-day.com/entertainment/bollywood-news/article/12th-fail-movie-review-vikrant-massey-anant-v-joshi-starrer-is-the-india-story-23316869. Accessed 21 January 2
024.
No comments:
Post a Comment